by skeeter » Tue Nov 17, 2009 2:53 am
I bought a case for $369 shipped from CDNN and when I got it the rounds were heavily tarnished but worse was that out of 100 rounds 15 rounds had what looked like deep gouges, like the brass was folded back on itself in the neck area. To CDNN's credit they issued me a free return shipping label and credited my card.
I then called Palmettostatearmory.com and asked how their ammo was. They said their ammo was not tarnished and had no gouges. I have bought from them mant times and they are great to deal with. I did not original buy from them because they asked $412 shipped but they said they would match CDNN's price. When I got the ammo it was nothing like the CDNN ammo. It was clean and no gouges. I noticed it had grey primer sealant rather than the heavily coated red sealant he CDNN ammo had. Again, I am talking about Federal's American Eagle black box 50BMG ammo.
I also have to say Summits ammo is first class and very clean. I would go with them before Fed. Am. Eagle. They say they keep the tolerances even closer with the once fired L.C. brass than with their new Winchester brass.